We do not take reservations, first come first serve!
Order here for pick up (limited menu) on Toast
– No Phone Calls Please –
For Special Events, Restaurant Buyouts, and Catering inquires, please click below:
SPECIALS
MONDAY: $17 any wood-fired pizza, select beers, and a Benchmark shot. (In-House Only)
THURSDAY: Trivia at 7:00 PM to win Paulie Gee’s Logan Square Gift Cards!
20″ NY style pizzas and NY Slices Available at our Wicker Park Location! Follow us: @PaulieGeesWickerPark
For private events, pop ups, and all sizes of catering, please contact [email protected]
Do you take reservations?
We do not take reservations, first come first serve! We do ask that your full party be at the restaurant before we seat you.
Do you offer take out and delivery?
We currently offer our limited take out menu through Toast for pickup! As our woodfired pizzas are thin and have very low thermal mass, we highly recommend reheating our pizzas briefly when you arrive home. Set your oven to 500 degrees, use a baking stone or steel if you have it, and heat in oven just until the cheese begin to bubble slightly. Our Logan Squares Detroit Style pies are ready to eat out of the box, but always better with a quick reheat as well!
Do you have gluten free options?
We do! We have an award winning gluten free Detroit style pizza dough, that can be incorporated with most of our Detroit style pizza menu!
We also have gluten free salads and desserts available!
How much Pie Pie My Darling Cake can I order?
Due to the popularity and the limited quantity of PiePieMyDarling’s amazing cake, each guest may purchase one slice of cake for each pizza purchase they make. This will apply to in house as well as take out.
Do you offer service for Special Events, Pop Ups, and Catering?
Yes! For private events, pop ups, and all sizes of catering, please contact [email protected]
